Tales From Alternate Earths – Reviewed

Tales From Alternate Earths: Eight broadcasts from parallel dimensions from Inklings Press, reviewed by E.M. Swift-Hook. Since this was written Daniel Benson has won the Best Short-Form Alternate History Sideways Award for his contribution to this anthology 'Treasure Fleet'. Brent A Harris & Ricardo Victoria were also finalists for their 'Twilight of the Mesozoic Moon'.

There is surely no other step-child in the weird and wacky family that makes up the genre known as ‘Speculative Fiction’, which is better suited to the short story format than alternative history. It allows an author to hone in on a point, even a single moment, in history and ask ‘what if something different happened?’ The answer is often not one that needs volumes to explore, but is better left to clever tending by an expert of bonsai literary expression. This anthology is a veritable greenhouse of such well-shaped bonsai.

Nuclear war actually having happened is the theme taken up by two of the authors, but with very different time points: ‘September 26th, 1983’ by Jessica Holmes and 1962 for ‘One World’ by Cathbad Maponus. One explores how Britain might be today if a Russian officer had not used cool headed common-sense back in the Eighties and the other is set in an America where the Cuban Missile crisis reached another possible conclusion.

“So, you said Oxford Street. This is Oxford Street. Anything special you want to see?”

Meteor strikes impacted enough to inspire the work of three of the authors in the anthology. ‘Stargazing on Oxford Street’ by Rob Edwards, has a view of how London could be which is very different to the one we have today. ‘Tunguska, 1987’ by Maria Haskins provides a totally original take on the cataclysmic event that flattened miles of forest in an isolated corner of the vast Siberian hinterland. ‘Twilight of the Mesozoic Moon’ by Brent A Harris & Ricardo Victoria is set in an almost unrecognisable alternative present day earth, but then the timeline as it is pictured here diverged in geological not historical time.

Away from the terrors of technology or the impact of astronomical objects, ‘Treasure Fleet’ by Daniel Bensen and ‘One More Dawn’ by Terri Pray both pose interesting and very human ‘what-ifs?’. ‘Treasure Fleet’ considers the idea of a medieval China converted to Islam and ‘One More Dawn’ is set in Ancient Egypt as a dying Pharaoh is tended by his loving wife.

“Um,” said Ogilvy, “I would say the chances are around a millio…”

Having a favourite in such a strongly written anthology as this is almost as impossible as having a favourite child – and may even be just as unethical, I am not sure. But I have to admit that I do have one: ‘The Secret War’ by Leo McBride. It is the one story that does the utterly unexpected and turns the idea of alternative history as approached by all the other stories in this collection completely on its head: what if a famous fictional story was really true? And then, when we have been brought to realise the impact of that, the author cleverly – and seamlessly – ties it into an equally famous real world event.

This collection of historical ‘what ifs?’ are each a near-perfect miniature cameo and a genuine delight. I can highly recommend it to all connoisseurs of speculative fiction, no matter which branch or sub-branch of the genre is their preferred regular perch. I think the only negative criticism I could offer is that the anthology includes more than one story drawing on the same actual event or very similar scenario. I think I might have possibly enjoyed the book just that little bit more if each story was tackling something unique from all the others – and the stories I appreciated the most were those that moved away from the more explored post-apocalyptic tropes and offered unexpected, unusual ‘what-ifs?’.

I really enjoyed how many of the authors pulled in a second – and sometimes even a third – historical variable, to help expand and explain the events of their stories. All the contributions are well written and polished, all impacting in their own unique ways, offering thought-provoking glimpses of how things could have been – IF….

5 Stars out of 5
This was written when the thought of actually being in an Inklings Press anthology was less than a twinkle in my eye!  Now the exciting news is that the next Inklings alt. hist. anthology will feature a Dai and Julia Mystery written especially and exclusively for it. So watch this space!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: